lichess.org
Donate

Timeout victory with only a Bishop... isn't this supposed to be a draw for insufficient material?

yes, but Lichess Rules work in a way, that any figure on board besides King is a victory on time
@aVague said in #2:
> yes, but Lichess Rules work in a way, that any figure on board besides King is a victory on time

If it's a king and bishop or a king and knight vs a lone king, It's still a draw since no checkmate is possible.

It's a difference between the USCF and FIDE rules regarding what constitutes "insufficient material". According to FIDE, If there is a checkmate possible, no matter how unlikely, it's considered sufficient material. According to USCF, sufficient material means you have enough material that you can theoretically force a checkmate if your opponent's pieces were all removed (thus a bishop alone is not considered sufficient).

This difference was highlighted in a game between Magnus Carlsen and Alireza Firouzja in the 2019 World blitz. Magnus Carlson only had a bishop, and Firouzja had three pawns and a bishop but ran out of time. According to FIDE, Magnus Carlsen won the game, however, had the tournament been played under USCF rules, it would have been a draw.
@Erlkonig1989 said in #4:
> If it's a king and bishop or a king and knight vs a lone king, It's still a draw since no checkmate is possible.
>
> It's a difference between the USCF and FIDE rules regarding what constitutes "insufficient material". According to FIDE, If there is a checkmate possible, no matter how unlikely, it's considered sufficient material. According to USCF, sufficient material means you have enough material that you can theoretically force a checkmate if your opponent's pieces were all removed (thus a bishop alone is not considered sufficient).
>
> This difference was highlighted in a game between Magnus Carlsen and Alireza Firouzja in the 2019 World blitz. Magnus Carlson only had a bishop, and Firouzja had three pawns and a bishop but ran out of time. According to FIDE, Magnus Carlsen won the game, however, had the tournament been played under USCF rules, it would have been a draw.
I know, but Lichess made it in that way obvious
@AOOP09 said in #3:
... (Your opponent underpromoted to a bishop and decided to suffocate himself. How sad.)

There's something... poignantly absurd yet appropriate, about that.

This answers my question for me. Thanks all!

Coyote

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.